Do accessibility overlays work? What Irish data shows
Published · Updated
An accessibility overlay is a small piece of code that adds an accessibility button or toolbar to your website. Some also try to repair problems automatically while the page loads. They’re often sold as a quick way to make a website accessible, or even compliant with the law.
This guide looks at what European disability groups say about accessibility overlays, and what our own data on Irish websites shows. For what the law asks of your website, see our guide to the European Accessibility Act in Ireland.
The short answer
An overlay widget isn’t illegal, and some people find parts of it handy. The problem is the claim that it makes your website accessible or compliant. It doesn’t.
In our studies, sites with a widget did no better than sites without one.
What an overlay does
When someone visits a site with an overlay, they usually see a round button, often in a corner. Clicking it opens a menu with options like bigger text, higher contrast or a reading guide.
Some overlays go further. They run code in the background that tries to spot and fix problems, such as missing image descriptions, as the page loads.
What European disability groups say
In May 2023, the European Disability Forum and the International Association of Accessibility Professionals published a joint statement on accessibility overlays. Their conclusion is clear: “Overlays do not make the website accessible or compliant with European accessibility legislation.”
They make two more points in the full joint statement:
- Many overlay features copy things that browsers and phones already do, such as zoom and high contrast.
- Some overlays detect when someone is using assistive technology, like a screen reader. They point out that this can reveal a disability, and that information about disability is sensitive personal data.
The Overlay Fact Sheet, signed by many accessibility professionals, makes a similar case. It says no overlay product can make a website fully compliant with any existing accessibility standard.
A US case
In April 2025, the US Federal Trade Commission approved a final order requiring the overlay company accessiBe to pay $1 million. The FTC alleged that claims that its widget could make any website compliant with WCAG were false, misleading or unsubstantiated. You can read the FTC’s announcement.
That’s a US case under US law. But it shows that regulators are looking at what these products claim.
What our data shows
We scanned the homepages of 12,397 Irish business websites across our studies. Our checks ran with the widget loaded, the way a visitor sees the site.
Across all our studies, 87 sites had an overlay widget. Of those, 83 (95%) still had at least one serious or critical accessibility failure. Among the 12,310 sites without a widget, the figure was 92%.
So sites with a widget did no better. Here’s how it breaks down by study:
- In our study of Irish business websites, all 76 sites with a widget had a serious or critical failure. That’s 100%, against 93% of sites without one.
- In our study of Irish local services, it went the other way. 7 of 11 sites with a widget (64%) had a serious failure, against 90% without.
- None of the 608 hotel websites we tested had a widget.
The 4 widget sites that passed were all using the same widget, UserWay, and all in the local services study. That’s a small group, and it shouldn’t be read either way.
Be careful with these numbers
These are small samples: 87 sites out of more than 12,000. This isn’t proof that widgets make things worse, or that they never help.
And automated checks only find roughly a third of accessibility problems. A widget can hide some automated failures without making a site any easier to use. A site that passes an automated check with a widget switched on still needs testing by people.
The honest summary is this: in our data, a widget didn’t stop sites failing.
Why a widget can’t fix the basics
Most accessibility problems are built into the page itself. A button with no name, a form with no labels, or a menu you can’t open with a keyboard. Code that runs on top of the page can guess at fixes. But it can’t always know what a button does or what a photo shows.
People who rely on assistive technology usually have their own setup. The disability groups’ statement points out that an overlay can get in the way of those tools.
What people already use
Most people who need help to use a website already have it, built into their phone or computer:
- Zoom and bigger text. Every phone and browser can make text bigger.
- Screen readers. iPhones, Android phones, Windows and Macs all come with one.
- High contrast and dark mode. These are settings on most phones and computers.
These tools work on every website, not just yours. So the most useful thing you can do is make sure your site works well with them. That means proper labels, real buttons, readable text and zoom left switched on.
If someone offers you a widget
If someone offers you an overlay widget, a few honest questions help:
- Will it fix the problems in my website’s code, or only on top of it?
- Will my site still work for someone who uses their own screen reader or zoom?
- Will you guarantee in writing that it makes my site compliant?
The disability groups’ statement and our data both point the same way: towards fixing the site itself.
What to do instead
Fix the problems in the website itself. These six cause most failures in our data, and each has a plain-English guide:
- Hard-to-read text: fixing colour contrast
- Links that say nothing: fixing empty links
- Images with no description: writing alt text
- Zoom turned off: letting people pinch to zoom
- Buttons that say nothing: fixing buttons with no name
- Maps and videos with no title: fixing embedded content
If your website runs on WordPress, our guide to WordPress accessibility explains how to tell a useful accessibility plugin from a toolbar widget.
If you already have a widget
The fixes still need doing. A widget doesn’t count towards them.
If customers tell you it gets in the way of their own tools, or your own testing shows it does, take it off. Then run our free scan to see what’s underneath.
What the law asks
The European Accessibility Act asks for a website that disabled people can use. A widget on top doesn’t change what’s underneath. Our guide to the European Accessibility Act in Ireland explains what it asks of your website.
This isn’t legal advice. For exactly how the rules apply to your business, talk to a solicitor or the relevant regulator.