EAA penalties in Ireland: what the rules actually say
Published
If you’ve searched for EAA penalties in Ireland, you’ve probably seen some big numbers. Some pages quote fines of €100,000, or a share of your yearly turnover. Those figures aren’t in the Irish rules.
This guide sets out what the rules actually say, in the order things happen. It’s not meant to frighten you. Most of the process is about getting problems fixed. For the bigger picture, see our guide to the European Accessibility Act in Ireland.
The rules this comes from
The European Accessibility Act (EAA) is an EU law. Ireland brought it in with the European Union (Accessibility Requirements of Products and Services) Regulations 2023, S.I. No. 636/2023. We’ll call them the Irish rules. You can read the Irish rules (S.I. No. 636/2023) in full.
Everything below comes from those rules. Each point names the regulation, so you or your solicitor can check it.
First, though: microenterprises providing services are exempt from the service rules (Regulation 5(4)). That means fewer than 10 people, and turnover or balance sheet of €2 million or less. Our guide to the microenterprise exemption helps you check. If you’re exempt, most of this guide likely won’t apply to your website.
In a nutshell
- A regulator has to warn you in writing before it gives you a formal order to fix something.
- You get 14 days to reply, and you can appeal to the District Court.
- Fines go up to €5,000 in the District Court, and up to €60,000 in a higher court.
- Taking all reasonable care is a defence, so keep records of what you’ve done.
The steps, in order
1. A written notice
A direction is a formal order from a regulator to fix something. Before giving you one, the regulator must write to you first (Regulation 27).
That notice must give its reasons. You then have 14 days to make written representations, which means writing back with your side. The regulator must consider what you say.
2. A direction
If the regulator still thinks there’s a problem, it can give you a direction. It must be in writing. It has to say:
- what’s wrong
- what you have to do
- the date you have to do it by
You must do what the direction says by that date. Then you confirm in writing, within 7 days of the deadline, that you’ve done it. The regulator confirms back within a month.
3. An appeal
You can appeal a direction to the District Court within 14 days (Regulation 28).
An appeal doesn’t pause the direction. You still have to comply while it’s heard, unless the court says otherwise.
4. A court order
A regulator can ask the Circuit Court to order you to comply (Regulation 29). Before it does, it has to give you another notice and another 14 days.
Customers can go to court too. A consumer can ask the Circuit Court for an order making a business comply (Regulation 30). Organisations can support them in doing this (Regulation 30(10)).
5. Prosecution
The last step is a criminal prosecution for an offence. The next section explains what counts as an offence.
One thing to be clear about: not meeting the accessibility requirements is an offence in its own right. So the steps above describe how the process is built, not a promise that every case starts at step 1.
What counts as an offence
Under Regulation 32 of the Irish rules, these are offences:
- not meeting the accessibility requirements (Regulation 5(1))
- not complying with a direction in time
- not complying with a court order
- obstructing an authorised officer (more on officers below)
- giving false information
The accessibility statement
Covered businesses have to publish information about how their service meets the requirements (Regulation 14). Most people call this an accessibility statement.
As we read it, the duty in Regulation 14 isn’t in the list of offences in Regulation 32(1). That doesn’t make it optional. A regulator can likely give you a direction to fix a missing or poor statement. Not complying with a direction in time is an offence.
So the safe course is simple: if you’re covered, publish one. Our guide to accessibility statements has a template.
The penalties
The penalties are in Regulation 32(6). There are two levels.
Summary conviction. This is a case heard in the District Court. The penalty is a class A fine, or up to 6 months in prison, or both. A class A fine is up to €5,000, under section 3 of the Fines Act 2010.
Conviction on indictment. This is a more serious case, heard in a higher court. The penalty is a fine of up to €60,000, or up to 18 months in prison, or both.
Those are maximums, not set amounts. When deciding a penalty, the court must consider (Regulation 32(7)):
- how serious the failure was
- how many products or services it covered
- how many people it affected
The Irish rules don’t set any fine as a share of your turnover.
Company officers
If a company commits an offence, its officers can be liable too. That’s if the offence happened with their consent or connivance, or through their wilful neglect (Regulation 33).
The defence of due diligence
It’s a defence to show you took all reasonable precautions and exercised due diligence to avoid the offence (Regulation 34). Due diligence means taking proper care.
This is why records matter. More on that at the end.
Who prosecutes
Summary offences are prosecuted by the regulator for that area (Regulation 35):
- the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC), which covers online shops and e-books
- ComReg, for phone and internet services
- the Central Bank of Ireland, for consumer banking
- the National Transport Authority, for bus, rail and ferry services
- the Irish Aviation Authority, for air passenger services
- Coimisiún na Meán, for TV and video services
If you sell online, the CCPC is the regulator you’ll deal with. It has a clear page on what the Act means for businesses.
Authorised officers
Regulators can appoint authorised officers (Regulation 31). An officer can:
- enter business premises
- inspect records
- ask for information
A private home is different. An officer needs your consent or a District Court warrant to go into one. That matters if you run your business from home.
Complaints
If someone complains to a regulator, the regulator must acknowledge it and consider it. Then it must tell the person the outcome (Regulation 41). It can decline complaints that are frivolous.
So a customer who can’t use your website has a clear route to the regulator. Often the better outcome for everyone is that they tell you first, and you fix it.
What this means in practice
Most Irish business websites have work to do. In our study of 6,576 Irish business websites, 94% had at least one serious or critical accessibility failure. Our studies check homepages only, and automated checks find roughly a third of problems.
Three things put you in a good position.
1. Fix the common problems. These six cause most failures, and each has a plain-English guide:
- Hard-to-read text: fixing colour contrast
- Links that say nothing: fixing empty links
- Images with no description: writing alt text
- Zoom turned off: letting people pinch to zoom
- Buttons that say nothing: fixing buttons with no name
- Maps and videos with no title: fixing embedded content
2. Publish an accessibility statement. If you’re covered, use our accessibility statement template. Be honest in it about what still needs work.
3. Keep records of what you’ve done. Note the date of each scan or check, what you found and what you fixed. Keep emails with your web developer and your suppliers. If a question ever comes up, records like these can help show you took reasonable care.
Run our free scan to see where your website stands. Save the report it emails you. That’s your first record.
Our guide to the European Accessibility Act in Ireland explains who the rules cover and what your website has to do.
This isn’t legal advice. For exactly how the rules apply to your business, talk to a solicitor or the relevant regulator.