Shopify accessibility: what 1,004 Irish stores show
Published
Shopify accessibility comes down to two things: what Shopify builds, and what you add to it. Shopify runs the platform and sets rules for the themes in its store. Your theme, apps, colours and images are up to you.
We tested 1,004 Irish Shopify stores. In our study of Irish Shopify stores, 96% had at least one serious or critical accessibility failure on their homepage. Almost half (49%) had a critical one. To see how it compares with other platforms, read our guide to which website builder is most accessible.
What Shopify takes care of, and what you control
Shopify runs the platform, the checkout and the hosting. It also sets accessibility rules for themes sold in its Theme Store.
You control the parts that make up most of what customers see:
- Your theme: the design, menus, product cards and sliders
- Your apps: reviews, pop-ups, chat, wishlists and anything else you install
- Your colours: text, buttons and backgrounds in your theme settings
- Your images: product photos, banners, and the descriptions you give them
Most of the problems in our data come from these.
The six common failures
These are the six checks Irish websites fail most often. Here’s how often each one turned up among the 1,004 Shopify stores, with a guide to fixing it:
- Hard-to-read text: 76%. See fixing colour contrast.
- Links with no name: 56%. See fixing empty links.
- Images with no description: 26%. See how to write alt text.
- Buttons with no name: 15%. See fixing buttons with no name.
- Zoom turned off: 13%. See letting people pinch to zoom.
- Embeds with no title: 7%. See fixing embedded content.
Missing image descriptions are more common on Shopify than across Irish websites as a whole (26% against 22%). Product photos are a likely reason. Shopify lets you add alt text to every product photo, and our guide shows where.
Quick wins in your Shopify admin
Two of the common problems are things you can fix yourself today, with no code.
Add descriptions to your product photos. From your Shopify admin, go to Products and open a product. Click a photo, click Add alt text, type a short description and save. Shopify’s guide to adding alt text to product media has the full steps. Start with your best sellers.
Say what makes the product different from the one beside it: the colour, the material, the pattern. “Chunky wool scarf in forest green” tells a customer much more than “scarf”.
Check your colours. In the theme editor, open the settings and choose Colors. Most themes use colour schemes, and different sections can use different schemes. Check the text and button colours in each one with a free contrast checker. Our guide to fixing colour contrast explains how.
Then run our free scan again to see what’s changed.
Four problems that stand out on Shopify
Four failures showed up far more on Shopify stores than on any other platform in our data. On other platforms with 100 or more sites, none of these went above 6%.
Hidden content you can still reach by keyboard (15%). Something is hidden from screen readers, but a keyboard user can still tab to it. This usually comes from menus, drawers and pop-ups that are closed but still on the page. Someone tabs into a menu they can’t see.
Controls inside other controls (13%). For example, a button placed inside a link. Screen readers often can’t tell what it is or announce it properly. This often turns up on product cards. The whole card is a link, and the “Add to basket” or wishlist button sits inside it.
Accessibility code on the wrong elements (12%). Accessibility code (called ARIA) tells screen readers what something is. Here, it’s been used on elements it isn’t allowed on, so screen readers may announce the wrong thing. This often comes from sliders, tabs and app widgets.
Scrollable areas keyboard users can’t reach (12%). A box that scrolls, like a product slider or a size chart, but that a keyboard user can’t move into. They can’t see what’s inside. This usually comes from sliders and carousels.
These all live in your theme or apps, not your content. So they’re a job for your theme or app developer.
If our scan flags any of them, copy this and send it to whoever looks after your store:
Our store fails some automated accessibility checks that usually come from the theme or apps: hidden content that can still be reached by keyboard, controls nested inside other controls, ARIA used on the wrong elements, and scrollable areas that keyboard users can’t reach. Can you tell me which theme sections or apps cause them, and whether they can be fixed?
Choosing a theme
Themes in the Shopify Theme Store have to meet Shopify’s theme requirements. These include:
- an average Lighthouse accessibility score of at least 90 across the home, product and collection pages, on desktop and mobile
- every part of the page working with a keyboard, including dropdown menus
- a visible focus state on anything you can tab to, so keyboard users can see where they are
- an alt attribute on every image
That’s a good starting point. But two things to know.
First, these rules only apply to themes listed in the Theme Store. A theme bought somewhere else hasn’t had to meet them.
Second, a score of 90 isn’t the same as accessible. Lighthouse is an automated check, and automated checks find roughly a third of problems. The theme can also change once you add your own colours, images and apps.
When choosing a theme, try its demo store with your keyboard. Press Tab to move through the page. Can you open the menu, choose a size and add something to your basket? Can you always see where you are?
Converge Accessibility has an article on accessible Shopify themes.
Checking apps
Every app you add puts its own code on your store. We couldn’t find accessibility rules for apps in Shopify’s App Store requirements, so check each one yourself.
Pop-ups, reviews, chat bubbles and wishlist buttons are common sources of the problems above. Before you install an app, run our free scan on your store. Run it again after. If new failures appear, ask the app developer about them.
Be wary of apps that add an accessibility toolbar or promise to make your store compliant. All four Shopify stores in our study with an overlay widget still had a serious or critical failure. Our guide to accessibility overlays explains why.
Your accessibility statement
Only 2% of the 1,004 Shopify stores we tested linked to an accessibility statement from their homepage.
If your store is covered by the European Accessibility Act, you likely need one, unless you’re a microenterprise. Our guide to accessibility statements explains what to put in it, with a template you can copy.
How Shopify accessibility compares
Shopify stores did about as well as WordPress sites in our data, and worse than Squarespace and Wix. Our guide to which website builder is most accessible compares them all.
Our studies check homepages only, so your product and checkout pages may have other problems. Our online shop accessibility checklist takes you through them, from search to order confirmation. Start with the fixes above, then run our free scan to see where you stand.