Online shop accessibility checklist: what Irish shops fail most
Published
Most accessibility checklists follow the order of WCAG, the international guidelines for accessible websites. This one follows the order Irish online shops actually fail. Start at the top and you’ll fix the most common problems first.
In our study of Irish online shops, 97% of 2,385 had at least one serious or critical accessibility failure. Only 2% (48 shops) linked to an accessibility statement from their homepage.
Our study checks homepages only, and automated checks find roughly a third of problems. So this checklist has two halves: things a scan can find, and things you need to test by hand.
You can print this page, or download the checklist as a text file.
Part 1: the big six
These are the six most common failures on Irish online shops, in order. The figure is the share of the 2,385 shops that failed each one.
- Text you can read (81%). Check that all text, including prices, sale badges and grey small print, stands out clearly from its background. Fixing colour contrast
- Links that say where they go (66%). Check that icon links, like your basket, account and social media icons, have a readable name. Fixing empty links
- Images with descriptions (22%). Check that every product photo has a short description of what it shows, and that decorative images are marked as decorative. Writing alt text
- Zoom left on (19%). Check that customers can pinch to zoom on your shop on a phone. Letting people zoom
- Buttons that say what they do (16%). Check that icon buttons, like search, menu, close and the arrows on sliders, have a readable name. Fixing buttons with no name
- Embeds with titles (8%). Check that every video, map or widget in a frame has a title that says what it is. Fixing embedded content
Part 2: problems that come from your theme and apps
These turn up more on online shops than on other websites. They usually come from the theme or apps, not from anything you typed. So they’re usually a job for your developer.
- Hidden content you can still reach by keyboard (9%). Check that closed menus, drawers and pop-ups can’t be reached with the Tab key.
- Controls inside other controls (7%). Check that buttons, such as “Add to basket” or a wishlist heart, aren’t inside a product link.
- Accessibility code on the wrong elements (7%). Check that sliders, tabs and app widgets don’t use accessibility code (called ARIA) where it isn’t allowed.
Our guide to Shopify accessibility explains each of these in more detail, with a message you can send to your developer. It applies to other platforms too.
Five more to check
These were next on the list. Each affected between 4% and 12% of Irish online shops.
- Lists built properly (12%). Check that menus and product grids are built as proper lists. This combines two checks: lists built incorrectly, and list items outside a list.
- Scrollable areas you can reach by keyboard (7%). Check that product sliders and size charts can be scrolled with the keyboard.
- Links you can spot without colour (7%). Check that links in your text are underlined, not just a different colour.
- Widgets with all their parts (6%). Check that tabs, menus and drop-downs have all the parts screen readers expect.
- Form fields with labels (4%). Check that every box, like search, email sign-up and quantity, has a label.
Part 3: from search to checkout, tested by hand
Our scan doesn’t reach these pages, so test them yourself. Put your mouse aside and use only the keyboard:
- Tab moves forward. Shift and Tab moves back.
- Enter follows a link or presses a button.
- Space ticks a box or presses a button.
- Escape closes a pop-up.
At each stage, check that you can always see where you are on the page.
- Search and filters. Tab to the search box, type a word and press Enter. Then tick a filter with Space. Check that the results change and that you can still find your place.
- Choosing a size or colour. Tab to the size and colour options. Check that you can choose one with Enter or Space, and that the choice is shown in words, not only by colour. If they’re drop-downs, check that each one has a label, like “Size”. Fixing drop-down menus with no label
- Adding to the basket. Press Enter on “Add to basket”. If a pop-up or side drawer opens, check that you’re taken into it, and that Escape closes it.
- Changing quantities. In the basket, change the quantity and remove an item. Check that the plus and minus buttons and the remove button all work with Enter.
- Checkout forms. Tab through every box. Check that each one has a visible label above it, not just grey text inside the box. Then leave a box empty and try to continue. Check that the error message says what’s wrong and how to fix it.
- Payment. Check that you can reach the card boxes and the pay button with Tab. If a security check opens, such as a bank’s confirmation screen, check that you can get through it with the keyboard.
- Order confirmation. Check that the page clearly says the order went through, in text, with the order number.
If anything on this list fails because of an app or payment provider, ask the supplier about it. Then run our free scan again. W3C’s Easy Checks are a free way to check a few basics by hand.
Part 4: what the European Accessibility Act adds for shops
The European Accessibility Act (EAA) is an EU law. In Ireland it’s in S.I. No. 636/2023, which we call the Irish rules. It likely applies to your shop if you sell to consumers online, unless you’re a microenterprise.
A microenterprise has fewer than 10 people, and turnover or balance sheet of €2 million or less. Microenterprises providing services are exempt from the service rules. Our guide to the microenterprise exemption helps you check.
The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) explains what the Act means for businesses.
For online shops, the Irish rules add two things (Schedule 1, Part 4(g)):
- Product accessibility information. When a manufacturer gives accessibility information about a product you sell, pass it on to your customers.
- Accessible identification, security and payment. Check that customers can log in, prove who they are and pay, whatever their disability.
And for all covered services:
- An accessibility statement. Publish information about how your shop meets the requirements (Regulation 14). Our guide to accessibility statements has a template.
Our guide to the European Accessibility Act in Ireland explains the rest. Our guide to what happens if you don’t comply explains the process.
Part 5: coming with WCAG 2.2
Right now, most businesses work to WCAG 2.1 AA. A newer version, WCAG 2.2, adds a handful of checks. Our guide to WCAG 2.1, WCAG 2.2 and EN 301 549 explains where that stands.
Four of the new checks matter most for shops:
- Tap targets big enough. Check that buttons and links, like the plus and minus in your basket, are easy to tap on a phone.
- Nothing hidden behind sticky bars. Check that a sticky header, cookie bar or chat bubble never covers the thing you’ve tabbed to.
- No asking twice. Check that customers don’t have to type the same details twice at checkout, such as their address. A “same as delivery address” tick box solves this.
- No memory puzzles to log in. Check that customers can paste a password and use a password manager, and aren’t asked to solve a puzzle to sign in.
If you’re changing theme or adding a new checkout, ask for WCAG 2.2 AA from the start.
Skip the shortcuts
Some apps and plugins add an accessibility toolbar and promise to make your shop compliant. They can’t fix the problems on this list. Our guide to accessibility overlays explains why.
More for your platform
When you’ve worked through Part 1, run our free scan to see what’s left on your homepage and key pages.
This isn’t legal advice. For exactly how the rules apply to your business, talk to a solicitor or the relevant regulator.